I love reading books on a small eInk reader. A friend recently lent me a printed book (War by Bob Woodward) and I was enjoying reading it but not enjoying carrying it around so I purchased the book from the Kindle store.
My local library in Kyneton is part of the Goldfields Library Corporation and they have agreements with several eBook lending systems including BorrowBox and Libby. The Kindle does not support eBook borrowing - they want you to buy from their store.
Another thing the Kindle doesn't support is the Pocket read it later service. (There is some sort of workaround that uses the email to Kindle service).
I've purchased a Kobo Clara BW. (I have little interest in a lower contrast colour eInk device).
The Kobo is a bit smaller than the Kindle I have and the screen is set in from the face unlike the Kindle. It charges and connects with USB-C. Setup was quite easy, I gave it the Wifi credentials and it did a software update.
The first thing I tried was plugging it in to my Mac. It mounts as a disk. I copied over an old MOBI format book and it appeared in the library. MOBI is an old Kindle format that they still support but don't recommend. (I think the DRM has been well and truly cracked). Kobo supports a range of formats natively including ePub, PDF, FlePub, TXT, HTML, RTF and also MOBI.
The MOBI file I copied over works well enough on the Kobo but I noticed some visible formatting incantations in the text. Perhaps their MOBI implementation isn't complete?
I favour ePub and while you can put them on a Kindle you must email them to get them converted.
eBooks from the Library
Setting up the Kobo to be able to browse and download loan eBooks from my library account was a bit of a puzzle. I went to the Discover tab and selected OverDrive (which is the way one accesses BorrowBox). It asked me to add my library. I tried Kyneton without luck, next I tried Goldfields. Finally I found a library in Ballarat and, guessing that it might be in the Goldfields group, chose that. Next I entered my library card number and PIN and it worked!
I am able to scroll through or search for books they have available. They do make it look like you need to purchase the book but tapping the three dot button shows an option to "Borrow with OverDrive". I sucessfully borrowed a book which quickly downloaded. It expires in 14 days.
The option to borrow rather than buy is well hidden. Dark pattern there from someone...
Pocket
Pocket is a service from the FireFox folks where you click a button in your web browser while viewing a story you want to read later and it magically gets cleaned up and sent to your reader. On the Kobo, this is in the More tab and they call it "My Articles" (although the pocket logo is easily recognised.
I had a bit of trouble getting the autentication to work and the Kobo said at one point they were having trouble too and are working on it. I tried again and it went through.
After sending an article to Pocket on my desktop computer I found that I need to tell Pocket on the Kobo to "refresh" (in the ... menu) in order to get what's new. I do like the fact that Pocket documents are separate to books rather than being mingled as they were on the Kindle.
Borrowing eBooks from a library is rediculously confusing. Things have different names, authentication seems unreliable, and I doubt that normal library users would figure it out. Perhaps Libraries are not motivated to make it easy?
Conclusion
So far I like the Kobo. I notice a bug where it seems to think I'm just 1% through books in the main listing even though I'm much more than that. Long tap to show the dictionary definition of a word doesn't work with MOBI books so perhaps that's also why the MOBI book I'm reading doesn't show progress.